Quick answer: Should I launch on Product Hunt, Indie Hackers or Hacker News?
- Product Hunt: a free 24-hour launch from 12:01 AM PT; editorial featuring, then a leaderboard.
- Hacker News (Show HN): free; something people can try now; no landing pages or sign-up pages.
- Indie Hackers: a founder community sharing strategies and revenue numbers.
- Best first stop for dev tools: Show HN.
- Best for a big launch day: Product Hunt.
- Best for an ongoing story: Indie Hackers.
Key takeaways
- These aren't three versions of the same thing: a launch, a feedback thread and a community.
- Show HN and Product Hunt both need a product people can use today.
- Indie Hackers rewards honesty over time: numbers, lessons, progress.
- All three punish self-promotion without substance and forbid vote-asking.
- Each fades in days; add a page that keeps ranking.
Founders often treat Product Hunt, Indie Hackers and Hacker News as three places to post the same announcement. That's the fastest way to get ignored by all three. Each community rewards something different: Product Hunt a usable product on one day, Hacker News something you can try and take apart, Indie Hackers an honest story told over time. This comparison sets out the rules and the fit, from each site's own pages, read on 17 November 2026. Jump to the comparison, each site or the order.
At a glance
| Product Hunt | Hacker News (Show HN) | Indie Hackers | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A daily launch leaderboard | A Show section of a tech news site | A founder community |
| Format | 24 hours from 12:01 AM PT | A thread; shownew, then Show past a points threshold | Posts and discussions over time |
| Who decides | Editors feature; leaderboard ranks | Community votes | Community engagement |
| Needs | A usable product | Something people can try now | A story worth sharing |
| Not allowed | Asking for upvotes; company accounts | Landing pages, sign-up pages; asking friends to vote | Ads without substance |
| Best for | A big launch day, awards | Technical feedback | Building in public, lessons, numbers |
Table: Product Hunt vs Hacker News vs Indie Hackers (each site's own pages, checked 17 Nov 2026)
Product Hunt

Free to launch, comment and win Product of the Day. Its team hand-picks launches to feature; featured launches compete on points, comments, time and other signals. Ask people to try it and give feedback, never to upvote.
Hacker News (Show HN)

For "something you've made that other people can play with". Link to the thing itself, explain how and why you built it, and stay to discuss. Every Show HN appears on shownew; after a small points threshold, on the Show page. Our Show HN guide has the details.
Indie Hackers

Indie Hackers describes itself as a place to "connect with developers sharing the strategies and revenue numbers behind their companies and side projects". The posts that do well share real numbers, failures and lessons. Treat it as an ongoing relationship, not a launch day. See our Indie Hackers guide.
The order that usually works

- While building: Indie Hackers — share progress and decisions; earn a following.
- When it's try-able: Show HN — sharp feedback while you can still change things.
- When it's polished: Product Hunt — a broad launch day, 1–30 days scheduled ahead.
- After: back to Indie Hackers — share the results honestly.
- Always: a permanent page — discovery that doesn't fade.
A permanent page alongside them

Ready to launch?
How we compared them
Rules come from Product Hunt's help centre, the Show HN guidelines and Indie Hackers' own homepage, read on 17 November 2026. The suggested order is our editorial recommendation. Science of Apps runs the Launchpad and has no relationship with these sites.
Key terms, defined
- Show HN: a Hacker News post sharing something people can try.
- shownew: the newest Show HN posts.
- Featured: a Product Hunt launch picked for the homepage.
- Build in public: sharing progress openly as you build.
- Indie hacker: a founder building a profitable business, often alone or with a small team.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, Product Hunt or Hacker News?
For a broad launch day with an award and a permanent Product Page, Product Hunt. For candid technical feedback on something people can try right now, Show HN on Hacker News. Developer tools often start on Show HN, then launch on Product Hunt.
Can I launch on Indie Hackers?
Indie Hackers is a community rather than a launch leaderboard: founders share the strategies and revenue numbers behind their companies and side projects. Share your launch as a story, with what you built, why and what you learned, rather than an advert.
Can I post a landing page on Show HN?
No. The Show HN guidelines say landing pages, sign-up pages, newsletters and fundraisers aren't Show HNs. Post when people can try the thing itself.
Is Product Hunt free?
Yes. Submitting a launch, commenting and reaching Product of the Day are all free, and Product Hunt says never to pay for upvotes.
Can I use all three?
Yes, and many founders do: build in public on Indie Hackers, post a Show HN when it's try-able, and launch on Product Hunt when it's polished, spacing them so you can act on feedback.
Can I ask friends to upvote on these sites?
No. Hacker News says asking friends to upvote or comment is not ok, and Product Hunt says asking for upvotes can get a launch removed.
Sources
- Product Hunt Help Center — How Product Hunt works (checked 17 Nov 2026)
- Product Hunt Help Center — How to promote your launch (and what to avoid) (checked 17 Nov 2026)
- Hacker News — Show HN guidelines (checked 17 Nov 2026)
- Indie Hackers — homepage (checked 17 Nov 2026)
- Science of Apps — Launchpad: launch your product free
- Checked November 17, 2026. Figures that change — fees, salaries, prices — are reviewed every six months; if something is out of date, tell us.
Where to go from here
- Show HN guide — post it right
- Indie Hackers guide — use the community well
- How to launch on Product Hunt — the step-by-step plan
- Science of Apps - LaunchpadHow to use Indie Hackers to launch and grow: what the community rewards, what to post, and how it fits with Product Hunt and Show HNHow to use Indie Hackers to launch: what the founder community rewards, posts that work, mistakes that get ignored, and where it fits with other launches.
- Science of Apps - LaunchpadHow to run a launch week, and why launching is a habit, not a day: every kind of launch a startup can do, from silent launches to feature dropsHow to run a launch week and launch repeatedly: silent launches, communities, Hacker News, Product Hunt, request-access waitlists and feature drops, in order.
- Science of Apps - LaunchpadHow to announce your product launch on LinkedIn and X: post templates, what to show, timing around a Product Hunt day, and the rules on asking for votesHow to announce a product launch on LinkedIn and X: copy-ready post templates, what to show, launch-day timing, and why never to ask for upvotes.
- Science of Apps - LaunchpadThe top 5 websites to launch your startup for free, checked against each site's own rulesThe 5 best free websites to launch a startup: Science of Apps Launchpad, Product Hunt, Show HN, Uneed and Peerlist, with costs, rules and who each one suits.
- Science of Apps - LaunchpadThe best BetaList alternatives in 2027: ten places to find early adopters, most of them freeThe best BetaList alternatives for 2027: free and cheap places to find early adopters, from Peerlist and Uneed to Indie Hackers and Microlaunch, checked.
- Science of Apps - LaunchpadHacker News Show HN: what qualifies, how to post, how it reaches the Show page, and how to handle the commentsHow to post a Show HN in 2027: what qualifies, the rules, how posts reach the Show page, how to write the post and how to handle Hacker News comments.
Get the ideas, not the noise.
Sign up with Google and we’ll send you short UX psychology tips by email — why people tap, stall and leave, and what to do about it. Unsubscribe anytime. Prefer something to keep? Get the free Laws of UX guide as a PDF.
Launch day ends. Your listing shouldn't.
Communities scroll on; a free Launchpad profile stays, ranked by relevance and never by payment, with your product tested end to end and a detailed report.





