Science of Apps - Launchpad · Playbook

Roast my startup: where to get
brutally honest feedback

To get your startup roasted, post on r/roastmystartup (a subreddit where founders ask for blunt feedback), Show HN if people can try it, Indie Hackers, or Microlaunch, whose launches collect 'roasts'. For an evidence-based roast of your live product, a free Science of Apps Launchpad listing includes a product test with a report on what to fix.

By , FounderUpdated 11 min read

Share

Quick answer: Where can I get my startup roasted for honest feedback?

  1. r/roastmystartup — a subreddit built for blunt feedback; the best posts draw dozens of comments.
  2. Show HN — free and candid, but only for things people can try right now.
  3. Indie Hackers — founders who share numbers; good for business-model roasts.
  4. Microlaunch — paid 30-day launches that collect feedback and 'roasts'.
  5. Science of Apps Launchpad — free listing plus a product test: an evidence-based roast of your live product.

Key takeaways

  • A roast is only useful if it's specific: ask about one screen, one promise or one price, not 'thoughts?'.
  • On r/roastmystartup, comments are the prize, not upvotes: in the month to 17 November 2026 the top posts scored under 10 but drew up to 48 comments.
  • Strangers can tell you where they got confused; only real users and evidence can tell you what to fix first.
  • Separate idea roasts (is this worth building?) from product roasts (why did I stop at sign-up?).
  • Reply to every comment and thank critics; harsh feedback in public is free research.

Your friends say it's great. Your mum says it's great. Your first ten users said nothing at all and left. That's why founders type "roast my startup": they want someone with no reason to be polite to tell them what's wrong. Done well, a public roast is the cheapest research you'll ever get. Done badly, it's a pile of hot takes. This guide covers where roasts actually happen, how to post so the feedback is specific, and how to get an evidence-based roast of your live product rather than opinions. Jump to where to post, how to write the post or what useful feedback looks like.

Where to get roasted · checked 17 Nov 2026

Where to get brutally honest startup feedback

  1. Science of Apps Launchpad With evidence

    An evidence-based roast: your live product tested end to end, with a report.

    Free listingFindings with proof
    Test free
  2. Hacker News (Show HN)

    Candid developers, for things they can try right now.

    FreeTry-it-now only
  3. Indie Hackers

    Founders who share revenue numbers; strong on business models.

    FreeBuild in public
  4. Microlaunch

    30-day launches that collect feedback and "roasts".

    From $4930 days
  5. Peerlist Launchpad

    A week of feedback from fellow builders.

    FreeEvery Monday

Where to get your startup roasted

Each place suits a different stage. Pick by what you want roasted.

PlaceBest for roastingCostWhat you get
r/roastmystartupIdeas, landing pages, early productsFreeBlunt comments from strangers
Hacker News (Show HN)Products people can try nowFreeCandid technical and product feedback
Indie HackersBusiness model, pricing, positioningFreeFeedback from founders who share numbers
MicrolaunchA launch with feedback built inFrom $4930 days of visibility, reviews and "roasts"
Peerlist LaunchpadSide projects and MVPsNo fee mentionedA week of comments from builders
Science of Apps LaunchpadYour live product, with evidenceFree listingA product test and a detailed report

Table: Where to get startup feedback, by what you want roasted (checked 17 Nov 2026)

r/roastmystartup: the subreddit built for it

r/roastmystartup is a subreddit where founders post a startup, idea or landing page and ask for blunt feedback. We pulled its top posts for the month to 17 November 2026: the highest scored under 10 points, but they drew up to 48 comments each, with a median of 18. That's the pattern to expect. Votes are low; detailed criticism is the payoff.

What the best-performing posts had in common:

  • A one-line pitch in the title: "I built a logo maker that charges once instead of monthly. Roast it."
  • Context in the body: who it's for, how it works, the price.
  • Specific questions: "Is anything confusing between concepts and checkout?" "Would you trust it enough to pay $49.99?"
  • A promise to reply: and then replying to every comment.

Read the subreddit's rules in the sidebar before posting; most founder communities remove drive-by links.

Hacker News (Show HN): candid, if people can try it

Hacker News Show page listing numbered Show HN posts with points and comment counts
Show HN: projects people can try, ranked by points.Image: Hacker News · Screenshot shown for commentary, 16 Nov 2026 · source

Show HN is for "something you've made that other people can play with". Its readers are mostly developers and technical founders, and the feedback can be blunt. The rules: no landing pages or sign-up pages, make it easy to try without an account, and don't ask friends to upvote or comment. Best for: developer tools and technical products.

Indie Hackers: roasts from founders who share numbers

Indie Hackers homepage with posts from founders about revenue, customers and marketing, plus a Submit a Post link
Indie Hackers: founders sharing the strategies and revenue numbers behind their products.Image: Indie Hackers · Screenshot shown for commentary, 17 Nov 2026 · source

Indie Hackers is a community where founders share the strategies and revenue numbers behind their companies and side projects. That makes it the best place to get your business roasted: pricing, positioning, channels and whether the numbers add up. Post as a story ("Month 3, $0 MRR, here's what I tried") rather than an ad, and ask what you'd change.

Microlaunch: a launch that collects roasts

Microlaunch homepage with a leaderboard of products scored on idea and product, with a Roasts column
Microlaunch: products scored on idea and product, with roasts.Image: Microlaunch · Screenshot shown for commentary, 17 Nov 2026 · source

Microlaunch runs 30-day launches and says you'll "receive honest feedback, roasts, and collect testimonials". Products on its leaderboard are scored separately on idea and product, with a count of roasts. Launch Pro costs $49 ($39 with the code on its page). Best for: a structured month of feedback around a launch.

Peerlist Launchpad: a week of builder feedback

Peerlist Launchpad showing this week's projects with upvotes and comments
Peerlist Launchpad: a new launch week every Monday.Image: Peerlist · Screenshot shown for commentary, 16 Nov 2026 · source

Launches open every Monday and run a week, from verified individual builders; no fee is mentioned. Comments come from people who build things too. Best for: side projects and MVPs.

The evidence-based roast: Science of Apps Launchpad

Science of Apps product investigation page with the headline Product intelligence that shows its work, describing a 360 degree investigation from first impression and onboarding to the core flow and paywall
The product investigation: every finding backed by a measurement or pinned to its screen, then signed off by an analyst.Image: Science of Apps · © Science of Apps · source

Public roasts tell you what strangers think. The product test tells you what happens. List your product free on the Launchpad, and once it's live it's put through a full investigation: loaded in a real browser on desktop and mobile, measured automatically, and the screens behind your login reviewed by experts the way a new user meets them, from the search result and landing page to sign-up, onboarding, the core task, the paywall and settings.

  1. Arrive

    First impression

    How findable you are on Google, AI assistants and social feeds; your landing page, pricing, trust signals; speed and stability.

  2. Join

    The first few minutes

    Sign-up, sign-in and recovery, and onboarding to the first moment of value.

  3. Use

    The everyday job

    The core task end to end, navigation, microcopy, and empty, loading and error states.

  4. Pay

    Where value turns into revenue

    The paywall, upgrade and checkout.

  5. Stay

    What brings people back

    Notifications, account, settings and help.

  6. Every screen

    Judged throughout

    Accessibility to WCAG 2.2, and visual design and consistency.

  • Evidence for every finding

    Backed by a measurement or pinned to the exact screen it came from. No roast without proof.

  • A verdict and a next step

    Good, Needs improvement, Needs to be fixed, Critical or Recommendation, so you know what to fix first.

  • The reason behind it

    Each finding cites the behavioural principle at work, from the 60 Laws of UX.

  • Checked by people

    An analyst approves, edits or rejects every finding before it reaches you.

  • Private by default

    Only your team sees it, and it never affects your listing's ranking.

Your roast, in print

Make your product live. Get it diagnosed today.

List free, and once it's live, order the report that fits your stage: what new customers see first, or the full diagnosis with a plan to fix it.

Economy

See what new customers see

  • Store listing and homepage, screen by screen
  • Scorecard against 60 Laws of UX
  • Customers, competitors and the fixes worth most
≈ 40 pagesDelivered within 3 hours
Most popular
Premium

The full diagnosis and the plan

  • Every screen, every finding, every flow
  • All 60 laws with evidence and fixes
  • 8 strategy chapters and a 90-day roadmap
≈ 95 pagesDelivered within 24 hours

Both reports are researched from your live product and fact-checked against the evidence before they reach you.

How to write a "roast my startup" post

Diagram of 6 steps for how to write a "roast my startup" post: 1. One line that says what it is; 2. Who it's for and where you are; 3. A link people can use; 4. What exactly to roast; 5. One screenshot; 6. Reply to everything.
How to write a "roast my startup" post
  1. One line that says what it is — "A budgeting app for couples who split rent", not "The future of money".
  2. Who it's for and where you are — "Six months in, 40 users, most stop at bank connection."
  3. A link people can use — no sales call, no waitlist if you can avoid it; a demo account if sign-up is heavy.
  4. What exactly to roast — two or three questions: the headline, the onboarding step where people drop, the price.
  5. One screenshot — of the screen you're asking about.
  6. Reply to everything — thank the harsh comments first; ask follow-ups ("what would you expect to see there?").

What useful feedback looks like

Useful (act on it)Not useful (thank and move on)
"Your headline doesn't say what it does.""This will never work."
"I couldn't find the price before signing up.""I'd never use this."
"Sign-up asked for my phone number first.""Just use [big competitor]."
"I didn't know what to type in the empty box.""Ugly design."

Table: Roast feedback you can act on, and feedback you can't

Look for patterns: if three people mention the same screen, that's your fix. One-off opinions are noise. Harsh comments also tell you how strangers see you; people judge a product by how it looks before they try it (aesthetic-usability effect), and a confusing first screen loses people before they read anything (cognitive load).

Mistakes founders make when asking for a roast

Checklist: Mistakes founders make when asking for a roast — Asking "thoughts?"; Arguing with critics; Roasting a landing page as if it were the product; Treating a roast as validation; Posting a broken flow; Dropping a link and leaving.
Mistakes founders make when asking for a roast
  • Asking "thoughts?" — vague questions get vague answers; ask about one thing
  • Arguing with critics — defending yourself stops the feedback; ask "what would you expect?"
  • Roasting a landing page as if it were the product — strangers can judge the pitch, not the product
  • Treating a roast as validation — praise from non-buyers doesn't mean anyone will pay
  • Posting a broken flow — test sign-up in a clean browser first
  • Dropping a link and leaving — communities can tell, and they stop helping

Ready for an honest look?

How we know

We pulled the top r/roastmystartup posts for the month to 17 November 2026 (through ScrapeCreators' Reddit data) to see what kinds of posts get detailed feedback, and read Show HN's guidelines, Microlaunch's launch page and Peerlist's rules on 16–17 November 2026. Science of Apps runs the Launchpad and the product investigation described above.

Key terms, defined

  • Roast: blunt, public feedback on a startup, idea or landing page.
  • Show HN: a Hacker News post sharing something people can try, with a title that starts "Show HN".
  • Build in public: sharing progress and numbers openly as you build.
  • Product investigation: a structured test of a live product, screen by screen, with findings backed by evidence.
  • Validation: evidence that people will use or pay for something, from conversations, sign-ups or pre-sales, not opinions.

Frequently asked questions

What is r/roastmystartup?

r/roastmystartup is a subreddit where founders post their startup, idea or landing page and ask for brutally honest feedback. In the month to 17 November 2026, its top posts had modest vote scores (under 10) but drew up to 48 comments each, which is the point: detailed criticism, not popularity. Read the subreddit's rules before posting.

Where can I get honest startup feedback?

For an idea: r/roastmystartup, Indie Hackers and founders you know. For a product people can try: Show HN and r/roastmystartup. For a launch with built-in feedback: Microlaunch or Peerlist. For evidence on your live product rather than opinions: a product test, such as the one included when you list free on Science of Apps Launchpad.

How do I write a 'roast my startup' post?

Say what it is in one line, who it's for, and what you want roasted: your landing page headline, the sign-up flow, or the price. Share a link people can use without a sales call, add one screenshot, and ask two or three specific questions. Then reply to every comment, especially the harsh ones.

Can AI roast my startup?

AI tools can give fast, general feedback on a landing page's clarity and copy, which is a cheap first pass. But they can't tell you where real users get stuck. Use AI to tidy the obvious, then get feedback from people who try the product and from an evidence-based test of the live flows.

Is it worth posting my startup idea for a roast before building?

Yes, for a sanity check, but don't treat it as validation. Strangers who will never pay can tell you what's unclear or what already exists, not whether people will buy. Validate with conversations and pre-sales from the people you're building for; see our guide to validating an app idea.

What makes a startup roast useful?

Specific, evidence-based criticism you can act on: 'your headline doesn't say what it does', 'I couldn't find pricing', 'sign-up asked for my phone number before I saw any value'. Vague hostility ('this will fail') isn't useful; thank the person and move on.

Sources

  1. Reddit — r/roastmystartup, top posts of the month (via ScrapeCreators, retrieved 17 Nov 2026)
  2. Hacker News — Show HN guidelines
  3. Indie Hackers — Homepage
  4. Microlaunch — Premium: how a launch works (checked 17 Nov 2026)
  5. Peerlist Help Center — Launchpad rules and guidelines
  6. Science of Apps — Product investigation: what we investigate and how
  7. Science of Apps — Launchpad: launch your product free
  8. Checked November 17, 2026. Figures that change — fees, salaries, prices — are reviewed every six months; if something is out of date, tell us.
Pass it on

Know someone who'd enjoy this?

Send it to them — one tap, no sign-up. Good ideas travel best between friends.

Keep exploring

Where to go from here

Join free

Get the ideas, not the noise.

Sign up with Google and we’ll send you short UX psychology tips by email — why people tap, stall and leave, and what to do about it. Unsubscribe anytime. Prefer something to keep? Get the free Laws of UX guide as a PDF.

Get the free Laws of UX PDFFree · no spam · unsubscribe anytime
Free, forever

Launch day ends. Your listing shouldn't.

An evidence-based roast of your live product: list it free on the Launchpad and get it tested end to end, with every finding backed by a measurement or pinned to the screen it came from.

Free PDF · 74 pages · 2 editions

The Laws of UX, in one field guide

60 research-backed principles in 6 categories — what each one means, why it works on the human brain and how to use it on your own screens. Written by Sushant Singh, founder of Science of Apps, who has scaled consumer apps to lacs of users and spent 10+ years leading product across startups and digital businesses in the US, EU & India.

Pick your edition
Free PDF · 90 pages · 2 editions

100+ Subscription Paywalls, decoded

110 real paywalls from top apps, taken apart, rated out of 5 and decoded with the Laws of UX — plus the frameworks, copy and checklists to ship your own. By Sushant Singh, founder of Science of Apps.

  • 110 paywalls rated
  • 34 Laws of UX
  • 12 frameworks

Which paywall scored 4.8 out of 5, and which scored 2.6? It’s all inside.

Pick your edition
Free PDF · 188 pages · 2 editions

Unmistakable: the logo book

How the world’s greatest logos are made, chosen and kept — and how to make yours. 98 short lessons and 19 true stories for founders, designers and the curious. By Sushant Singh, founder of Science of Apps.

  • 98 lessons
  • 19 true stories
  • 60+ real logos

Why did a $35 sketch become the Swoosh, and why did Gap lose its nerve in six days? It’s all inside.

Pick your edition